Resource Center:   Linux       Home/Home Office       Convergence      Enterprise       E-Biz  

Search Archive

Home Site Map Media Kit Print Media Kit Feedback Help  Newsletters jobs@Cybermedia Contact Us

• For the most updated version of this V&D100 survey data, go to voicendata.com • Learn about the upcoming CyberMedia events


Home > SOLUTIONS SPACE
 

 Brocade partners IBM to expand IP networking footprints in India
 HP launches 'Touchsmart' printers
 AMD appoints Nicholas Donofrio
 SITA to conduct three-day expo
 iBall introduces Li'l Book
 Indian CIOs more progressive compared to global counterparts: IBM
 Greenlight Technologies partners with Logica
 Unlimited access with Aten digital KVM extension solution
















Insight Enablers

Tyresoles increases productivity by 15%

Creating Enterprise Services Architeture Road Map

Visible benefits with ERP

In Trading improves business productivity by 40%

Godrej Case Study

Thin Is In
 
Continued from page: 1


 

 
Friday, September 07, 2007

 

TC vs PC
Though there is visible interest in the technology today, what is surprising is that Indians, who are quick adopters of technology, didn't lap up thin clients or take the bait then. The answer perhaps is in the fact that people saw it as a wait and watch period, or as Balaji of HCL put it, “No one want to be a first time buyer.”

There was also way too much dependence on PCs. People were just getting comfortable using PCs when all of a sudden a newer technology was introduced, and users were unsure of using a PC without a hard disk or local storage. Explaining the phenomenon, Adhikari said, “India is still on a learning curve of PCs, and the curve is currently at 60-70 percent. Organizations in India are still to learn the benefits of PCs, so while they are adapting to this technology, another one has been introduced. Hence, with this new technology, they may take time to adopt it.”

Earlier, thin clients also came with low memory. While some of the first thin clients available came with 1GB RAM, today, thin clients are available with 1GB flash memory.

Another problem is breaking the mindsets of people who depend on PCs. There are many who do not know the benefits of deploying thin clients. For them, the PC is at best cheaper and offers more utilities.

Though a thin client may not offer all the features that a PC may, its advantages far out number its cons. “The PC prices are our competitors. This is because we have to break a mindset. PCs are available at Rs 20,000. Thin clients start at Rs 25,000, plus Rs 5,000 for a monitor,” shared Adhikari.

Agreeing with him, Peer added that it is also difficult for an end-user to come to terms with the fact that his machine is no longer personal, hence the mindset towards thin clients.

  Why thin clients make sense

 

10 PCs vs 10 thin Clients

Features

Windows 2000 / Windows 2003

PCs with disk drives PCs with Thin Clients
Comparable hardware requirement Pentium 4 3.0D/256MB RAM/ 80 GB
HDD/keyboard/mouse/ 15” color monitor
Thin client PC / 128MB
RAM/keyboard/mouse/15” color monitor
Average cost of hardware Rs 21,000 Rs 13,000
Security Low and user dependent Full centralized security system
Maintenance Moderate to high Nil
Down time Varies Nil
User management Decentralized Highly simplified and centralized
Speed As per local speed At par with the server speed
Internet sharing Requires proxy Inbuilt
Cost of setting up 10 machine lab:
Server (1) Rs 35,000 Rs 35,000
Nodes (10) Rs 2,10,000 Rs 1,30,000
Networking expense Rs 5,000 Rs 5,000
Total expense Rs 2,50,000 Rs 1,70,000
Maintenance per year @ 8% per annul per machine Only server requires maintenance
Saving Rs 80,000  
Note: Cost comparison is based on computer hardware cost only
1. Savings on software licenses would be tremendous
2. Upgradation cost after three years, ie Smart Station requires server upgradation only
Source: Apurva Computers Technologies (This is an indicative office
environment)

Page(s)   1  2  3  4  


End of the article

Related CIOL links   External links  

 



Read Previous SOLUTIONS SPACE...






ZTE:Leading CDMA Technology


Extraordinary Networks:Freedom of Choice







Previous Stories

Should Linksys rest in peace?

Bet On Quality, Not On People

63 lakh PCs sold in India last fiscal: MAIT

Message boards

Discuss this and many other IT topics at the
CIOL message board

Google
  Web dqchannels.com

 
DQ Channels Other CyberMedia web sites   Cyber India Online Ltd.
 

 CyberMedia India Ltd
Copyright © CyberMedia All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.
Usage of this web site is subject to terms and conditions.
Broken links? Problems with site? Send email to webmasterciol@cybermedia.co.in